Consumer Directed Services or home health?
We run both services. People ask us all the time which one they need. The honest answer is that they fix different problems, and plenty of people need both.
The difference in one sentence
Home health treats a clinical problem and then stops. Consumer Directed Services supports daily living and continues for as long as you need it.
| Consumer Directed Services | Home health | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Non-medical personal care | Skilled clinical care — nursing and therapy |
| Who chooses the person | You do — anyone but your spouse | The agency assigns licensed staff |
| Who employs them | You are the employer; we are the fiscal agent | The agency |
| Can a relative be paid | Yes | No |
| Physician order required | No | Yes |
| Who decides eligibility | Missouri DHSS, after an in-home assessment | Your physician, plus your payer |
| How long it lasts | Ongoing, while you remain eligible | Episodic — it ends when the skilled need resolves |
| Typical pattern | Regular hours, often daily | Short visits, tapering over weeks |
| Paid by | MO HealthNet | MO HealthNet, private insurance, private pay |
You probably need home health if…
- You have a wound that needs professional care.
- You need injections, IV therapy, or catheter or ostomy care.
- You are recovering from a stroke, a fall, surgery or a hospital stay and need physical, occupational or speech therapy.
- A condition like heart failure or COPD needs clinical monitoring.
- Your physician has said you need skilled care at home.
See the home health services →
You probably need CDS if…
- What you need is help with bathing, dressing, meals, laundry and getting to appointments.
- The need is ongoing rather than tied to a particular illness.
- You want to choose who comes into your home — often a family member.
- You are a MO HealthNet participant, 18 or older, with a physical disability.
- You would rather direct your own care than have it managed for you.
Why people often need both
Here is how it often goes. Someone has a stroke and spends two weeks in hospital. They come home needing physical therapy, speech therapy, and a nurse to watch their new medicines. That is home health. Over a couple of months it does its job and stops.
What does not end is that they now need help bathing and dressing every morning. No clinical benefit covers that. If they are a MO HealthNet participant, Consumer Directed Services does — and their daughter can be the paid attendant.
The two can run at the same time. Receiving home health does not disqualify you from CDS, and having a CDS attendant does not prevent a home health referral. They are different benefits with different rules, and the aide who visits under a home health plan is a different arrangement from the attendant you employ. Aide vs. attendant →
What we do about the handover
The gap between the two is where families get hurt. Home health ends on schedule. Only afterwards does the family find out that nothing pays for the daily help their relative still needs. That discovery usually happens during a crisis.
Because both services sit inside one organization here, that conversation can happen before discharge instead of after. Our medical social workers raise it as a matter of course, and if CDS is the right fit we can start the process while home health is still running.
And if neither is right
Sometimes the answer is an agency-directed private-duty arrangement, or assisted living, or something else entirely. We will say so. Steering someone into a benefit that does not fit their situation wastes months they may not have.
Not sure which you need? Describe the situation and we will tell you.
Call (314) 809-6655 for a free consultation, or text (314) 886-5902. We serve St. Louis City, St. Louis County and Missouri communities within about 40 miles of our office.
